Seeking Friends

So where would we begin to find ‘friendship’?

C.S. Lewis warns us against looking too hard. Part of the difficulty is that ‘being friends’ is not about friendship. “That is why those pathetic people who simply ‘want friends’ can never make any.” (C. S. Lewis, The Four Loves, 80). Lewis portrays friends as those who stand side by side and gaze out at the world, in contrast to lovers whose gaze is fixed on each other. It is with this image in our minds that perhaps we can feel our way forward to friendship. Friendship arises not out of ‘naturalness’, sameness, or narcissism, but from a third: an object, goal, vision, project, vocation. Genuine friendship doesn’t arise from within friends, but between friends and an ‘outside’. It is essentially orientated away from the relationship itself.Seeking Friends Pathological, counterfeit relationships always fail to have this ‘other’ centred-ness: counterfeit love fails to be ‘other-person-centred’; counterfeit friendship fails to be ‘other-thing-centred’. This is why friendship is best understood in its traces, as Tennyson knew.
We study it when we are lonely.

Maybe there is another reason that friendship is hard to find: that it is somehow essentially resistant to definition. To begin with a definition is to seek the ‘sameness’ of friendships, to isolate the distinctive patterns and markings that make ‘friend’ into a kind. I don’t want for a minute to deny that there is something distinctive about this relation. But what if its distinctiveness lies in its freedom, in the basic unboundedness, the foundational non-obligation of the relationship which makes it into such a gift? If so, maybe we should start with the ‘different-ness’ of friends. Perhaps here we will find traces of the friend who is to come?

Image by Untitled Blue

One thought on “Seeking Friends

  1. Perhaps, if I may be metaphysical for a minute, you have wandered near to a distinctive feature of Triune relations. It is fairly commonplace to take it as given that talk about personal relationships is a matter of I/Thou in one form or another. Where the Christian doctrine of God is fixed almost exclusively on God/Jesus relations without appropriate space for an actual work of the Spirit then this two-phase metaphysic could easily stand behind the I/Thou. However, if the Spirit is an agent of personal constitution in the godhead, as Richard St. Victor promoted in the middle ages, then it takes the Spirit's third agency to create Fatherhood and Sonship. Hence it takes a third agent to create constructive inter-personal human relations – if human relations echo divine. So to be good friends, we need someone or possibly something in order to act as a mediator between us and towards the greater world outside our us-ness.


Comments are closed.